In Ronald Irving’s book The Law is A Ass there is a collection of anecdotes which augment legal quotations in context with the different parts of how law actually works in the judicial system. The scheme of the book is to convey philosophies, concepts, understandings and practices associated with Law and its appurtenances, which may not be amenable to a student of Law seeking answers to “what is the law”. However, no student of Law may ever be able to clearly claim that they never encountered perplexing philosophical question or a difficult question juxtaposing Law as it ‘is’ as against the Law as it ‘ought to be’. This book becomes important because of its capability to withstand such formalistic criticisms.
Volume 6, Issue 4 / 2024
Articles · 69
Intellectual Property (IP) has been traditionally categorized into Industrial property and Copyright. The term Industrial Property includes patents, trademarks, industrial designs, and geographic indications of source. Copyright protection is granted to protect literary, artistic and musical works. Rights related to copyright include those of performing artists in their performances, producers of phonograms in their recordings, and those of broadcasters in their radio and television program. Intellectual property rights are generally said to be a bundle of exclusive rights granted to the lawful owner. The Word A trademark is described as a symbol that may be visually represented and that can be used to identify one person's goods or services of one person from those of others and may include shape of goods, their packaging and combination of colours . According to Nordberg, it's critical to comprehend not only the distinction between a trademark and a brand, but also their mutually beneficial relationship. The word "well known mark" refers to a more general term that also includes connections created by a trademark, such as goodwill, image, and prestige, while "trademark" is the legal term that designates a distinctive mark or symbol to which an owner can get an exclusive right. Well known mark have the potential of attracting consumers, employees, financiers etc. and could be used to establish long lasting relationships on the market. According to Petrusson A well-known trademark may be seen as an intellectual phenomena that demonstrates a company's capacity to increase value for customers and other stakeholders. Popular brands are becoming more and more valued assets for businesses. They serve mainly as transporters of collected value from enterprises and as vehicles for communication. The story of the famous trademarks begins with the Paris Convention, moves on to the TRIPS Agreement, and ends with the WIPO recommendation. This Paper will give an Bird’s eye view on the Trademarks and wellknown marks and their application in the Intellectual Arena.
Hindu law views marriage as a holy and indestructible ritual, representing an enduring relationship that transcends lifetimes. In India, Hindu weddings are governed by the Hindu Marriage Act of 1955 (HMA), which also has judicial separation measures. Married couples may live apart without ending their marriage thanks to judicial separation, which gives them an opportunity to work things out before filing for divorce. This article offers a thorough analysis of judicial separation under the HMA, looking at its definition, significance, context, legal foundation, grounds for separation, procedural features, and ramifications. Couples can evaluate their marriage, get treatment, and perhaps prevent divorce through legal separation. The essay highlights the possibility of reconciliation and the maintenance of marital ties by drawing comparisons between legal separation and divorce. It also covers the function of counselling and mediation as well as the necessity of legislation changes to improve access to support services. Case laws are included to show how judicial separation is really applied in practice. In the end, the paper emphasizes how crucial judicial separation is as a way to resolve marital disputes while defending the family's interests and future.
This research paper delves into the intricate relationship between mental health and criminal responsibility, emphasising the pivotal role of forensic psychiatry in understanding legal implications. Beginning with exploring criminal responsibility and its link to mental health, the study highlights the significance of forensic psychiatry in legal contexts, particularly in conducting psychiatric evaluations to ascertain criminal responsibility. The paper examines the prevalence of mental health disorders in criminal cases and their impact on criminal behaviour, shedding light on the complexities of assessing mental health within the realm of criminal justice. It delves into the determinants of criminal responsibility in forensic psychiatry, various methods of assessing mental health in legal cases, and the challenges inherent in evaluating mental health for criminal responsibility. Furthermore, the research delves into the legal implications of mental health in criminal law, discussing the application of the insanity defence, legal standards for determining mental competence, and ethical dilemmas in assessing mental health for legal purposes. In conclusion, the paper synthesises vital findings and insights, proposing reforms in the criminal justice system to better address mental health issues in legal proceedings. It also identifies areas for further research and exploration to enhance our understanding of mental health in the context of criminal responsibility.
The Board of Directors of a Company play a key role in ensuring the sustenance and success of the Company. The major responsibilities of the Board of Directors include providing leadership and strategic guidance to the workforce of the organization, monitoring and supervising the day-to-day activities of the business and fulfilling the goals of the Company. Independence of the Board is important to ensure the implementation of best practices in the Organization. The Independent Directors form a crucial part of the Board of Directors. They aim to achieve good Corporate Governance by acting as a watchdog. They ensure the following: accountability of the Board of Directors, protection of the interests of the shareholders, prevention of oppression against the minority shareholders and improvement of internal controls.
This study examines the critical function that corporate governance plays in mergers and acquisitions (herein referred as M&A), clarifying how important it is to protect stakeholder interests at every stage of business transactions. This research, which is based on corporate governance principles, explores the fiduciary responsibilities of officers and directors and looks at how these duties affect the way decisions are made during mergers and acquisitions. Through an examination of the relationship between M&A dynamics and corporate governance procedures, this study sheds light on how strong governance frameworks reduce risks, improve transparency, and encourage responsibility in business dealings. Additionally, the importance of shareholders' empowerment through governance systems to protect their interests is highlighted, as is their role in influencing and examining M&A activity. The examination of industry best practices and regulatory frameworks governing M&A transactions highlights the changing governance and its effects on business conduct. By thoroughly analysing these aspects, this study advances our knowledge of how corporate governance principles can effectively negotiate the difficulties of mergers and acquisitions, eventually advancing and safeguarding stakeholders' interests in business transactions.
Euthanasia, derived from the Greek for "good death," addresses the ethical dilemma of alleviating suffering for terminally ill patients while navigating complex debates on personal autonomy and the sanctity of life. This research explores its historical evolution from ancient Greece, where it symbolized a dignified end, through periods of condemnation in the Middle Ages and Renaissance, to contemporary discussions spanning clinical, legal, political, religious, and ethical dimensions. Despite support from ethicists and utilitarian perspectives, euthanasia remains contentious, especially in Western Christian-majority countries, amidst advancements in life-prolonging therapies and palliative care. Different forms—voluntary, non-voluntary, involuntary, and assisted suicide—present unique ethical challenges, largely opposed by religious doctrines upholding the sanctity of life. Advocates argue euthanasia upholds autonomy, prevents undue suffering, and respects dignity, advocating for its legalization under stringent safeguards to prevent misuse and ensure equitable access. Opponents stress concerns about life devaluation, potential abuse, and ethical burdens on healthcare providers, advocating instead for enhanced palliative care to honor life without discrimination. Globally, legal approaches vary; Switzerland permits assisted suicide, Oregon's Death with Dignity Act allows physician-assisted death, and India recognizes passive euthanasia. High rates in Canada and the Netherlands reflect principles of individual rights and suffering relief, with evidence from Belgium and the Netherlands supporting coexistence with robust palliative care. Emphasizing a deontological framework, this research underscores patient autonomy and thorough decision-making processes. While advocating for improved palliative care, it supports euthanasia as a compassionate option for those facing unbearable suffering, ensuring strict guidelines preserve dignity and autonomy.
Advent of information technology affected every walk of life including the judicial system. Use of information technology and audio-video electronic means in day to day life led to the generation of new form of evidence i.e. electronic evidence. Electronic evidence was sought to be governed by insertion of provisions in the century old Indian Evidence Act, 1872 by Information Technology Act, 2000. Since the inception of the provisions relating to electronic evidence, the same have been subjected to varied judicial interpretations making it difficult for the parties to produce electronic evidence in Indian courts. Varied and often conflicting judgments and legislative gaps made it difficult for litigants to present electronic evidence in courts in India. To settle the law, the Constitutional Courts have interpreted the provisions and have given detailed standard operating procedure for identification, collection, production and admissibility of electronic evidence in India. In 2023, the Parliament of India came up with new criminal laws including the new law of evidence i.e. Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023. The Adhiniyam has amended the law relating to production and admissibility of electronic evidence. This paper explores the law relating to production and admissibility of electronic evidence from 2000 to 2024 in the light of relevant judicial decisions and amendments introduced. The paper analyses the difficulties posed by the judicial decisions and the amendments introduced by the Adhiniyam.
Digital Marketing is the New Black. Digital marketing is an umbrella term which refers to using digital channels, platforms and devices to market the product or service. Digital marketing helps one achieve a larger target across the globe than through the traditional methods. Gamification, being a part of digital marketing helps in consumer engagement and to grow brand awareness. This paper primarily focuses on digital marketing management and how gamification aids to marketing.
The latest trends promoting digital sovereignty are increasingly freeing us from the complexities and challenges of international law in cyberspace. The complexities and challenges of digital sovereignty lie in the ability to control and direct international actors through the use of digital technologies such as the Internet, social media, and other digital media.Although international law is still in its beginning there is an urgent need to determine how it will be applied in this area, but that is a long way to go and it is still in its infancy. This chapter is divided into two parts a brief overview of the existing challenges for international cyber law and a discussion on the impact of these challenges on the future of cyber security with the help of Human Rights. The lack of effective international legal instruments in cyberspace is widely debated in theoretical and political debates. The complexity of cyberspace makes it difficult for parties to reach agreements, let alone enact acceptable and binding laws. The contentious academic debates primarily divide those who believe that states should play a more influential role in formulating international cyberspace law and those who argue that cyberspace should remain a free and distributed domain.
Digitalization is the need of modern edge. India has adopted the same trend of digitalization like other nations as well. But in India protection of right to privacy and cyber security is one of the concern of contemporary India. Article 19 provides freedom of speech and expression with some reasonable restrictions. Freedom of speech and expression includes freedom of press. Right to privacy is also a fundamental right guaranteed under article 21. But in present society maximum population of current society of India is very much addicted to social media, social networking sites and with social entertainment apps. Due to digitalization internet baking and online payment apps are very much used by people. Digitalization is a progressive feature of a developing nation , though there are some positive effect in the country but on negative effect is also there specially cyber crime against citizens, some of the citizens are victims of cyber defamation, violation of right to privacy through hacking of social media profile of a person either common people or public figure, hacking of bank details, cybertheft of bank account. To protect citizens from cyber crime Information Technology Act,200 was passed by parliament of India. To protect the intermediaries inter mediary guidelines, 2018 and 2021 was passed by parliament of India, though there was Indian Penal code provides punishment for cyber crime. However, cyber is under control but it is still going on. India needs to strengthening cyber laws and needs improve cyber security and security officials should give advance training to fight with cyber crime. There is also need of strong government policies to make internet users aware against cyber crime and proper implementation of cyber law is essential for present society Of India.
It is trite in law that the sin must be punished and not the sinner. It is the reflection of the ancient philosophy of India and the various older civilisations of the world, the wiser and the more experienced, including the scriptures of all spiritual practices and the realizations of the great souls that it is the soul that matters and not the body. The soul and the metaphysical existence of the individuals matters and not the matter that is visible to the eye. Even Mahatma Gandhi and Nelson Mandela used to say and their sayings are the guiding light of this unenlightened world, that the punishment, although should be detrimental and extraordinarily harsh when it is a serious offence, but whereby the crime or the offence is petty- it should be such a punishment that does not feel like revenge, but does feel like a reformatory exercise. These thoughts have been reiterated by many legal academicians, social reformer, criminal law advocates, judges, and experienced legal scholars. Keeping in mind the same, the Indian governance system apparatus has recently, through the new criminal codes, namely Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023, has introduced the punishment of community service on the conviction of petty organised and petty crimes. The present short article manuscript will attempt to define community service which has not been defined, as such, and seek a better clarification on the operation of the same, while analyzing the socio-legal consequences of the same.
Censorship, the suppression or regulation of speech, media, or other public communication, has been a contentious issue worldwide, including in India. This article provides an in-depth analysis of censorship in India, examining its multifaceted impact on movies, general media, and books. By exploring the historical roots of censorship and its evolution, the article sheds light on how the practice has been used to maintain societal norms, political stability and public morals. Special attention is given to the role of the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) in regulating the film industry and the legal framework governing censorship as per the Cinematographic Act of 1952. The article discusses landmark cases such as K.A. Abbas v. Union of India, Bobby International v. Hoon, and Shreya Singhal v. Union of India, which have shaped the landscape of censorship in India. These cases illustrate the ongoing tension between the right to freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a) of the Indian Constitution and the state's authority to impose restrictions for various reasons, including national security, public order and morality. Through detailed analysis of specific instances of censorship in movies, media and literature, the article highlights both the protective and repressive aspects of censorship. It examines high-profile controversies like the banning of films such as "Padmaavat" and "India’s Daughter," censorship of books like Salman Rushdie's "The Satanic Verses" and the impact of media regulations on press freedom. By reviewing these diverse cases and their broader implications, the article aims to question whether current censorship practices in India strike a fair balance between safeguarding societal interests and upholding the fundamental right to free expression.
The criminal justice system in India is undergoing significant reforms aimed at modernizing and enhancing its efficiency, fairness, and responsiveness to societal needs. Recent legislative amendments, policy initiatives, and technological advancements are transforming the landscape of criminal justice in the country. The New Era of Criminal Justice in India is marked by efforts to streamline legal procedures, reduce case backlogs, and improve the accessibility of justice. Key reforms include the introduction of fast-track courts for handling specific types of cases, the digitization of court records, and the implementation of e-filing systems to expedite judicial processes. Additionally, there is a growing emphasis on protecting the rights of victims and witnesses, ensuring timely investigation and prosecution of crimes, and enhancing the capacity of law enforcement agencies through advanced training and better resources. The adoption of alternative dispute resolution mechanisms, such as mediation and plea bargaining, is also gaining momentum, providing more efficient and less adversarial means of resolving conflicts. Furthermore, the use of forensic technology and data analytics in criminal investigations is improving the accuracy and reliability of evidence. These reforms are complemented by initiatives to address systemic issues, such as corruption and human rights violations within the justice system. Overall, the New Era of Criminal Justice in India reflects a comprehensive approach to building a more transparent, accountable, and effective legal framework, aligning with global best practices while addressing the unique challenges of the Indian context. The object of the article to study the overview of the three new laws and the difference between the old la and new one. The research methodology involves secondary data from diverse sources including journals, articles, newspapers, magazines and online platforms.
Victimisation of children occurs both inside the care institutions and inside their own homes around the world, India being no exception. There have been many instances in which a child is sexually victimised inside the orphanages or educational institutions or shelter homes and most of the times these crimes even go unreported. Ministry of Women and Child Development, India in the year 2007 conducted a nationwide study of children aged between five and eighteen years of age and found out that a shocking 52.94 percent of boys had experiences some kind of sexual trauma and 23.06 percentage of them had faced a severe sexual assault. This research article aims to examine several elements of male child abuse, including the underreporting of such crimes and the related stigmas. The researcher will also study the impact such abuse has on a male child and how these cases of abuse are dealt with in India. Mapping the interventions of government as well non-governmental organizations, it further examines different practices and challenges faced in the process of addressing the issues emanating from the dominant notions of masculinities and sexuality in the context of India. The instances of such abuse are dealt under the POSCO Act, 2012 which was enacted by the government to bring the abusers to justice.
The patenting of microorganisms and other life forms presents a complex and contentious issues, especially when comparing the approaches of nascent patent regimes like India with those of developed regions such as Europe and the USA. As it is well known that, microorganisms are found naturally, forming a part of the ecosystem and they are discoverable per se and not inventible hence, why the question of them being patented arises? Where a line should be drawn if patenting of microorganisms and life forms are allowed, in order to maintain the balance between encouraging research and development and their exploitation? This paper examines how these regimes differ in their approach to the patentability of living organisms, highlighting India's proactive stance in implementing TRIPS mandates to foster research and development in biotechnology. The paper delves into the moral, legal, and ethical dilemmas associated with bio patenting, arguing for a balanced intellectual property regime that respects both commercial interests and public welfare. It underscores the importance of situational exceptions and flexibilities in the Indian IP framework to accommodate indigenous conditions while adhering to international agreements. The need for sensitivity towards public health and ethical concerns is emphasized, alongside a caution against unfounded mistrust of commercial entities to promote scientific advancement responsibly.
India is country where the population is the highest and we are ranking 1st in population. With the increase in population and technology and commercialization its not like that there will be no disputes at all with anybody and all are law abiding citizens. Theoretically this sounds good but practically its not possible in a country like India. When we are in Industrial Revolution 4.0 then and where AI is working then at some point dispute is going to arise which is an indispensable thing. If we take all such small/ big disputes to the court of Law then we can see that there will be a huge number of pending back-log of cases and the case registration number is an enormous one. If we only depend upon court to deliver justice then we don’t know when we will get justice. The only way to resolve is through the active participation in Lok Adalat as established under the Legal Service Authority Act and advocating the importance of Lok Adalat and how its functioning and creating an awareness/ sensitization of the people about the Lok Adalat as means of dispute resolution mechanism.
In the structure of Indian federalism the Governor holds a significant position and serves as the bridge between the central and state governments. This research aims to compare the role of state Governors with that of Lieutenant Governors in Union Territories (UTs). Governors in Indian states play crucial roles in legislative processes & exercises powers in areas such as law-making, state administration and emergency situations. On the other hand, Lieutenant Governors in UTs without legislative assemblies have a more pronounced executive role and operate under the direct supervision of the President of India. By examining their roles, the study highlights the varied administrative needs and governance models adopted in states and UTs and contribute to a deeper understanding of India's federal structure.
Cooperative banks are subject to the Reserve Bank's statutory powers of regulation and supervision under the 1949 Banking Regulation Act. However, the Registrars of Cooperative Societies of the States concerned retain their authority over these banks' incorporation, management, etc., incorporation, management, etc., of these banks. It is further stated that the provisions of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (as applicable to Cooperative Societies) shall be supplementary to, and not, save as expressly specified in the Act, in derogation of, any other law for the time being in force. This means that cooperative banks must follow not just the Banking Regulation Act, but also any additional legislation that may be relevant to them. The requirements of the Banking Regulation Act must take precedence over the provisions of the Cooperative Societies Act concerning matters specifically established in the Banking Regulation Act. By including Section 56 of the Act, cooperative banks were rendered subject to it in 1966. As the name implies, members of a cooperative bank serve as both the bank's owners and its customers. Members of the same local community, or profession, or who share a shared interest will typically form a cooperative bank. In general, members of cooperative banks have access to a wide variety of banking and financial services (loans, deposits, checking accounts, etc.). The structure, mission, values, and management of cooperative banks are distinct from those of stockholder banks. They are treated similarly to stockholder banks in most countries because of their oversight and control by banking regulators and compliance with prudential banking standards. This regulation and oversight may be exercised directly by government agencies in certain nations, while in others it may be entrusted to a federation or centralized body of cooperatives. The term "cooperative banking" refers to the cooperative structure of both retail and commercial banking. Most of the world's population has access to cooperative banking institutions that accept deposits and make loans. Commercial banking services supplied by manual organizations (such as cooperative federations) to cooperative firms are included in the broader category of "cooperative banking," which also include retail banking as practiced by credit unions, common savings and loan associations, building societies, and cooperatives. Comparatively, cooperative banks have a three-tiered federal structure, while commercial banks use a branch banking model.
The notion of stringent criminal punishment has been misconceived over the death penalty. Even though, the death sentence in India is not imposed based on no evidence and arbitrarily or without any logical reasoning, Death over another death questions the deterrent effect of the death penalty. It creates a situation of duty of the state vs. the state as a murderer where the question of morality and inhumane violation of human rights arises. This paper focuses on the effectiveness of the death penalty and emphasizes the alternatives with parlance to global views on the death sentence. The paper makes a critical analysis of the executions of the past 5 years and the constitutional validity of the Death penalty.
AI raises a lot of concerns for judges and legal systems. The potential benefits of AI for court administration and the accompanying requirements are important factors to take into account. Regardless of the kind of case, the fundamental goal of legal processes is the simplification of complexity. Not every legal assignment requires sophisticated bespoke work. As a result, different types of IT, such as artificial intelligence, show varying degrees of applicability in different scenarios. As part of larger changes, the Chinese authorities and judicial system have chosen in recent years to heavily integrate artificial intelligence. This significant use of AI in the judicial system is unique to China and is the result of enduring problems the courts face, such an extreme increase in their cases and a lack of qualified staff. As a result, a number of pilot operations have been started around the country, integrating different AI systems into different areas of the legal system. Lately, artificial intelligence has also been integrated into the Indian legal system. This article examines the shortcomings in the Indian legal system's effective integration of artificial intelligence (AI) and offers remedial strategies based on the Chinese model that may be used to ensure the continued growth and successful integration of AI in India's law system.
Forensic science’s pivotal role in judgement delivery is exemplified in the above named case, where DNA testing challenged traditional legal presumptions. With advancements in science, Courts are increasingly relying on scientific evidence to ensure fair and just outcomes, but with caution as demonstrated in this judgement.
The recent Amendment Bill proposes substantial reforms to India's criminal law framework, addressing outdated aspects of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), the Indian Evidence Act, and the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC). Rooted in the colonial era, these laws have struggled to manage modern challenges like cybercrime, economic offenses, and human rights issues. The Bill introduces new criminal classifications, with stricter penalties for offenses such as cybercrime. It also aims to streamline judicial processes through measures like the electronic filing of FIRs and video conferencing. Furthermore, it prioritizes victim rights and witness protection, offering financial support, counseling, and safeguards against intimidation. Despite these promising reforms, the Bill presents several challenges. It necessitates comprehensive training for law enforcement, the judiciary, and legal professionals to adapt to the new legal landscape. Additionally, the reliance on advanced technology requires significant investment in digital infrastructure, especially in rural and underserved areas. The Bill's emphasis on centralized control has raised concerns about diminishing state autonomy in criminal law. Moreover, it is crucial to ensure that marginalized populations benefit equally from these changes, addressing issues like the digital divide and varying literacy levels. The success of these reforms hinges on careful implementation, ongoing assessment, and a collaborative effort among all stakeholders to achieve a more equitable and efficient legal system in India.
Section 3(d) of the Patent Act recognizes innovations that stands the 3-pronged test of Patents: “inventive step”, “non- obviousness”, and “industrial application” thereby preventing a phenomenon called “evergreening of patents” which applies to secondary patents. Moreover, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the Novartis case (2013) rooted for a narrow and strict interpretation of this provision. However, the question in discussion primarily focuses on the legal and economic consequences of applying different rules of interpretation to this provision with hypothetical illustrations. Firstly, the literal interpretation appears to overlook factors such as utility, public importance and intention of the legislation. Secondly, a liberal approach does not effectively prevent evergreening of patents and also has major economic consequences. Lastly, the mischief rule overcomes the fallacies in other approach but does not detach the ambiguity. In addition to this, this paper focuses on the nuances of the effect of such constitutionally valid provision on day-to-day Patent application. The provision, though prima facie appears to be non- arbitrary, statistics prove that objections under Section 3(d) have been overutilized to deny primary patents. Finally, it is asserted that there is a need to amend the provision to specifically address the threshold for ‘new forms of discovery’ and ‘new forms of invention’ to suit all rules of interpretation. Further, “efficacy” shall not only mean “therapeutic efficacy”, but shall be justiciable as to expansively read it to include factors such as bio availability, potentable, shelf life, quick healing or any other corresponding factors which will keep the test of patentability intact.
The evolving landscape of intellectual property rights (IPR) and their intersection with alternative dispute resolution (ADR) mechanisms have become pivotal topics in legal discourse. IPR protects creators' interests, yet disputes in this realm are inevitable, particularly in the digital age. Although Indian courts acknowledge the arbitrability of IPR disputes, a definitive procedure is lacking due to the absence of a statutory mandate for ADR in these cases, leading to inefficiencies and inconsistencies. This paper advocates for aligning Indian law with international developments in IPR arbitration to foster a conducive business environment, protect intellectual property, and encourage innovation. Legislative reforms are proposed to codify and standardize IPR dispute resolution in India, enhancing its global standing in the IPR landscape. Key cases, including Booz Allen and Hamilton Inc v SBI Home Finance Ltd, Eros International Media Ltd v Telemax Links India Pvt Ltd, and IPRS v Entertainment Network, illustrate the complexities and inconsistencies in judicial rulings on IPR arbitrability. Comparative analysis of global practices, such as those in France, Singapore, and Hong Kong, highlights the potential benefits of embracing arbitration for IPR disputes. The paper suggests amending the Arbitration and Conciliation Act and various intellectual property statutes to explicitly include ADR mechanisms and provide clear guidelines for arbitrability. These reforms aim to ensure efficient, fair, and consistent resolution of IPR disputes in India.
Indian Constitution under Article 72 empowers the President to grant pardons and Article 161 grants powers to the governor to pardon the sentence except in a few cases. It can be granted to individuals who have been convicted of any offence against a law or sentenced by a court martial (military court) and for sentence of death. The object of pardoning power is to correct possible judicial errors, for no human system of judicial administration can be free from imperfections. Pardoning is an act of kindness that reduces the punishment conferred under the law for the offence and restores the rights and privileges lost on account of the offence. The present paper envisages to critically reviewing the pardoning powers exercised by the President of India who has been granted the responsibility and authority to protect the Constitution.
The protection of human rights is a fundamental cornerstone of a just and equitable society. Human rights violations persist worldwide, necessitating robust mechanisms to safeguard individuals and groups from abuse. This topic explores the essential principles and frameworks for protecting human rights, including international law, national legislation, and institutional mechanisms. It examines the roles of governments, civil society, and individuals in promoting and protecting human rights, with a focus on vulnerable populations and emerging challenges. By understanding the complexities of human rights protection, we can work towards a world where dignity, equality, and justice are universally respected and protected. And I would also like to share my personal experience and practical approach in the human rights commission that I have learnt during my internship program.
This paper focus on to which extent constitutional mandate has been implemented. Child labour is a vexed subject in India. People often think about it with their hearts rather with their heads. Child labour represents a fundamental abuse of child right and a violation of various laws. There are specific clauses in the draft of Indian Constitution dated 26th January, 1950 about the Child Labour Policy in India. These are conveyed through different articles in the Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles of the State Policy. They lay down specific policy rules regarding child labour in Articles 14, 15(3), 23, 24, 38, 39(e), 39(f), 41, 42, 45, 46 and 47. It was also decided that both the Union and State Government could legislate on matters concerning child labour. Various legislative initiatives were also taken in this regard at both the State and the Union level. But still Statics reveal that India is the largest example of a nation plagued by the problem of child labour – 218 million. All of the policies that the Indian Government has in place are in accordance with the Constitution of India, and all support the eradication of Child Labour. Yhis problem still remains even though all these policies are existent. Enforcement is the key aspect that is lacking in the government’s efforts. No enforcement data for child labour laws are available. “A glaring sign of neglect of their duties by officials charged with enforcing child labour laws is the failure to collect, maintain and disseminate accurate statistics regarding enforcement efforts.” If child labour is to be eradicated in India, the government and those responsible for enforcement need to start doing their jobs. Policies can and will be developed concerning child labour, but without enforcement they are all useless. Indian laws become unpractical and redundant in the face of necessity. The proposed paper examines how far the constitutional mandate of child labour has been given a practical shape and to what extent the mandate has been enforced and implemented in India. At end paper suggests some strategies to control the child labour in India.
The article discusses the evolving landscape of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), emphasizing the transition from arbitration to mediation. It underscores the challenges that government entities encounter when utilizing arbitration as a tool for resolving disputes. Well-structured, the article thoroughly examines each issue that disputing parties, particularly the government, face in arbitration proceedings. Beyond merely outlining these difficulties, it delves into the judicial obstacles related to the interpretation of the Arbitration Act of 1996. In conclusion, the article provides a brief analysis of the Mediation Act, highlighting its potential benefits and implications for future dispute resolution.
The article titled “An Analyses of the new mediation act” focuses on to carry out a comprehensive study of the new statute. Article starts with a study of the Preamble of the act followed by a study of few of the key provisions of the act. It is to be noted that the article is completely based upon my understanding of the act and no secondary materials were used. The article identifies few key provisions which may create a pit fall in the application of the act. Not only the pitfalls are marked out a substantial reasoning is also provided for the same in order to substantiate my point.
The Constitution is known as the “law of the land or living law of the country”. It can be compared to “grundnorm” of Kelson and thus it is the legitimacy criteria of validity of any law or any executive action in India. The Indian Constitution has served as a check and balance between the necessity of adhering to or following procedural rules and the flexibility to meet the requirements of the changing society. Transformative constitutionalism, which is essential to the evolution of society toward greater democracy and progress, is one of the most important features of the constitution. Transformational constitutionalism is a methodical approach that prioritizes safeguarding each person's fundamental rights and liberties in order to achieve the objectives of the constitution. The Indian Constitution is based on the idea that the machinery of law may be used to achieve significant objectives for improving the societal wants in an electoral democracy. The Supreme Court acts as the guardian and interpreter of the Constitution, along with growing recognition that the Indian Constitution is a flexible rather than a rigid one and has allowed it to implement these changes acknowledging its need. The philosophy of transformational constitutionalism has been strengthened by a number of recent Supreme Court rulings.
This paper provides a comparative analysis of the legal and ethical frameworks governing gene editing and patenting in India and the European Union (EU). Both regions welcome advancements in gene editing but impose stringent restrictions to maintain ethical compliance and public safety. The Indian Patent Act, with Sections 3(b), 3(c), and 3(j), and the EU's morality and ordre public doctrines limit the patentability of genetic modifications. While India permits gene editing in plant biotechnology, biomedical research faces tighter regulations under the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) and the Department of Biotechnology (DBT). Similarly, the EU's regulatory bodies maintain strict oversight to prevent unethical practices. This paper discusses the evolving guidelines, including India's 2020 draft by DBT and CDSCO, and the EU's established frameworks, highlighting their approaches to balancing innovation and ethical integrity. By comparing these regulations, the paper elucidates how both regions navigate the complexities of gene editing to foster advancements while safeguarding societal values.
The emerging realisation that identification of an eyewitness evidence is just not as trustworthy as it once was formerly thought being is among the most significant outcomes of utilising postconviction DNA testing in the legal system for crimes. In 75 percent of US DNA exonerations, incorrect witness identifications served as the main justification for erroneous convictions. Despite advancements in science concerning Courts have not shown how human memory and other factors can affect eyewitness identifications a strong inclination to employ this scientific understanding when making decisions on cases. Two scenarios have been chosen for consideration in this article. The New Jersey Supreme Court was the first in State and Federal jurisdictions in the US to rule in S v. Henderson 27 A 3d 872 (NJ 2011) that evaluated eyewitness testimony using a science-based methodology. Another case being discussed is S v. Mdlongwa 2010 2 SACR 419 (SCA), a ruling by the Appellate Court of South Africa, where the offender was found using the testimony of an expert on CCTV footage and an eyewitness narrative. The research findings on estimator variables recognised in S v. Henderson are covered in part one of this article. The purpose of part two is to examine S v. Mdlongwa in particular to ascertain the degree which the results of psychological study on eyewitness reliability are acknowledged in South Africa. The Henderson court recognised that the laws controlling the use and admissibility of identifying the results of numerous social science studies were far behind the evidence. Additional State courts across the US have taken note of the new wave that S v. Henderson introduced. For instance, The members of the Supreme Court in Massachusetts organised an eyewitness evidence study group and the report that came out of it suggested, among other things, that judges be made aware of contemporary psychological concepts, that guidelines for identifying eyewitnesses to the jury be updated, and that judges and attorneys should continue their education. In South Africa, these aspects may and must to be acknowledged and taught about.
For an extensive period of time Independent Directors have been considered as an important pillar of Corporate Governance in the Companies. Their primary function is to bring an independent and unbiased perspective to the board in order to manage the interests of the shareholder and the management of the company. This research article focuses on the concept of the independent directors, its evolution and its significance and relevance in the contemporary legal corporate structure. This article also focuses on the concept of the corporate governance, its origin, and the meaning that it has acquired in today’s time. With a focus on the roles and responsibilities of the independent directors per se and their involvement in ensuring that the corporate functions prudently and runs its business legitimately while conforming to the rules and regulations that govern its working.
This article aims at investigating the criminalization of Triple Talaq in India through a critical analysis of The Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act, 2019. Triple Talaq, a practice wherein a Muslim husband can divorce his wife by uttering the word ‘Talaq’ three times has been a subject of intense debate and legal scrutiny. This article explores the landmark case of Shayara Bano v. Union of India to understand the constitutional debate that disseminated before the declaration of the unconstitutionality of Triple Talaq by the Apex Court of India. The paper mainly focuses on the examination of the legislative response to this judgment of the Supreme Court which culminated in the enactment of The Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act, 2019 and its alignment with the principles of equality and gender justice. It focuses on the socio-legal implications of the Act in order to provide a comprehensive understanding of its effectiveness. It further provides various suggestions for the policymakers in order to effectively address the identified loopholes and drawbacks in the legislation.
The paper explores the relationship between pharmaceutical patents and public health and how intellectual property laws influence access to essential medicines. Patents are crucial in encouraging innovation but can create monopolies that limit access to lifesaving medicine. This has been a great problem, especially in developing countries where high prices of drugs are an issue to the efforts done about public health. The paper critically analyses the global and Indian views on this issue. It discusses how drug patents, through the provision of exclusive rights, have the dual effect of incentivising research and development and creating barriers to access to essential medicines. Here, key global frameworks— the TRIPS Agreement and the Doha Declaration— are brought to the fore to balance intellectual property rights and public health imperatives. Within an Indian framework, this paper discusses legislative measures like compulsory licensing and recent development news of the Union Budget 2024 exempting three cancer drugs from customs duties- a positive sign of initiation to improve the approach towards critical treatments, which further signifies that flexible patent policies need to be framed looking at public health objectives. The paper concludes by making recommendations on how to change patent protection rules by reducing the duration and the scope of pharmaceutical patents and actively using compulsory licensing as a means to address the overpricing and access issues with current patent regimes, which in the end would make the health system more equitable. The paper argues for a balanced approach that supports innovation and public health by reassessing patent laws and including measures like exempting targeted customs duties.
The Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act, 1994 (THOTA) in India was enacted to regulate the transplantation of organs, prevent commercial exploitation, and promote ethical practices. This paper critically examines the provisions of THOTA, its amendments, and their effectiveness in addressing organ trafficking and promoting deceased organ donation. This paper aims to critically assess THOTA's regulatory framework, examining its provisions and amendments, enforcement challenges, and societal implications. By analyzing these factors, the study seeks to offer insights into improving THOTA's effectiveness, enhancing ethical practices, and ensuring equitable access to life-saving organ transplants in India. It discusses key provisions, including brain-stem death certification, authorization committees, and penalties for violations. Challenges such as ambiguity in 'affection or attachment' criteria and the prosecution of offenders are analyzed. The study concludes with recommendations for strengthening THOTA to meet current healthcare needs while curbing illegal organ trade.
Human rights are universal, inalienable entitlements and freedoms that transcend distinctions of color, caste, or gender. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1948, formed a pillar of this global human rights movement and was subsequently used as an inspiring document and played a major role in upholding Human Rights worldwide. The long arc of India’s struggle for human rights has interacted with modern influences like UDHR and framed its constitutional framework to enforce this simmering fuse phosphate in its supreme law. The Indian judiciary with its activist voice interpreted human rights in the finest form possible through several landmark judgments. These judgments played a crucial role in defining the history and the future of Indian human rights activism. Notable cases like Maneka Gandhi, and Kesavananda Bharati carry an upper hand in the dynamic evolution of human rights in the Indian context. Thus, the paper fundamentally talks about the indispensable role played by the Indian judiciary in safeguarding the human rights of its individuals.
Divorce can be a profoundly challenging experience, especially for children caught in the middle of judicial separation. In India, where the family unit is often considered sacrosanct, divorce can have unique implications for children, both psychologically and socially. This article explores the effects of divorce on children in India, legal provisions and landmark judgments related to child custody, and suggests ways to support children through this difficult transition. Divorce in India, where family ties are deeply valued, presents unique challenges for children caught in the crossfire of judicial separation. This article delves into the emotional, social, and academic impacts of divorce on children, highlighting the psychological distress and behavioural challenges they often face. The legal framework in India, governed by a mix of personal and secular laws, aims to protect children's welfare during custody disputes. Landmark judgments have underscored the importance of prioritizing the child's best interests, leading to evolving practices in child custody arrangements. Additionally, the article explores pathways for supporting children through this challenging time, offering practical recommendations for parents, educators, legal professionals, and policymakers. By fostering open communication, maintaining consistent routines, and advocating for a child-centric approach, society can help mitigate the adverse effects of divorce on children and empower them to thrive despite the challenges.
As Artificial Intelligence (AI) rapidly advances, the debate surrounding the rights and responsibilities of sentient AI entities intensifies. This chapter delves into AI ethics to propose a comprehensive legal framework for defining the rights and responsibilities of such entities. Examining philosophical, ethical, and legal perspectives on AI sentience, it addresses the implications of attributing human-like qualities to AI systems. The literature review explores AI ethics, AI personhood, and existing legal frameworks regarding AI rights and liabilities. Progress in deep learning, natural language processing, and human-like behaviors in AI raises questions about consciousness, autonomy, and moral agency in General AI. The ethical aspect is central to the AI personhood debate, questioning whether AI entities can experience consciousness and possess intrinsic value, challenging traditional ethical norms. The consequences of granting AI personhood extend to privacy, freedom from discrimination, and human-AI relationship dynamics. The paper analyses global legal landscapes, studying laws and policies addressing AI rights and responsibilities. While some countries are looking to recognize AI as legal persons or grant specific rights, others adopt property-based approaches. Key court rulings and case studies involving AI entities shape future legal precedents. To address defining AI rights and responsibilities, the paper proposes a comprehensive legal blueprint. Balancing potential AI sentience with societal interests outlines guidelines for determining AI personhood and allocating responsibilities to developers, owners, and users. Emphasizing international collaboration and standardization, the paper highlights the importance of a coherent global policy safeguarding human interests and upholding ethical principles regarding AI personhood. In conclusion, this research contributes to the discourse on AI and sentience's legal implications. Exploring ethical and legal dimensions, aids policymakers, researchers, and stakeholders in crafting responsible regulations embracing AI's potential while safeguarding human rights and societal welfare.
The continuous progression of Competition Law in the Indian Pharmaceutical Industry is a dynamic and evolving endeavor. India's Competition law, implemented in 2002, is relatively recent in comparison to other global competition laws. The regulatory landscape of the Indian pharmaceutical industry raises issues due to its distinct attributes. The industry being examined is the largest in terms of global scale, and it poses a unique challenge due to the inherent nature of its products, which are medicines. The question at hand pertains to the attainment of equilibrium between the concerns of innovators and the welfare of consumers. This suggests that it is crucial to find an optimal selling price for the good in question. Setting prices too low may discourage enterprises from engaging in its production, resulting in limited availability and accessibility. This is particularly concerning when considering that the product in question is critically important for society as a whole. On the other hand, exorbitant prices would make the product inaccessible, so potentially adversely impacting consumers.
In a world where the focus of gender-based violence has primarily been on women, the plight of men who suffer in silence demands our attention. Violence against men remains an unheard and uncounted reality, hidden behind societal misconceptions and a lack of awareness. This research paper aims to break the silence and shed light on this often-neglected issue, specifically within the context of India. By uncovering the truth, we can pave the way for meaningful change, challenging existing norms and advocating for the well-being of all individuals. To better understand the magnitude of violence against men, we explore the global ranking of different countries, delving into comprehensive data and statistics. By identifying the best and worst performers in combating this issue, we gain valuable insights into the broader context, highlighting the urgency of addressing the problem in India. This global perspective enables us to access the gravity of the issue and advocate for change on an international scale. This research paper delves into the multifaceted challenges faced by men who experience violence in India. By examining societal norms, stereotypes, and ingrained biases, we shed light on the obstacles that prevent men from reporting their experiences or seeking support. Additionally, we explore the gaps in legal protection and support systems, addressing the systematic issues that perpetuate the cycle of violence. By understanding these issues, we can develop targeted interventions to ensure the safety and well-being of male victims. Drawing upon relevant ranks and data, this paper presents a comprehensive overview of the status of violence against men in India. By examining the constitutional provisions, existing laws, government schemes, and the role of NGOs, we gain insights into the current landscape. Furthermore, we identify the gaps and areas that require immediate attention, advocating for necessary legal reforms and the strengthening of support systems to address the issue effectively. Informed by comprehensive reports and successful practices from grassroots and global perspectives, this research paper provides actionable suggestions to combat violence against men in India. These suggestions encompass legal reforms, awareness campaigns, training programs, and the establishment of robust support systems at various levels. By implementing these solutions, we can strive towards a society that recognizes and addresses the unheard and uncounted violence faced by men, fostering a safer environment for all individuals. While progress has been made in addressing violence against men, there is still much work to be done, by aligning our targets with achievable goals and accelerating actions, we can effectively address the issue and ensure the well-being and safety of all individuals. Through a multidimensional approach involving collaboration between government agencies, NGOs, and civil society, we can strive for a society that recognizes and addresses the unheard and uncounted violence faced by men. Together, we can unveil the truth and work towards a more inclusive and equitable society.
Efficient and fair tax administration relies heavily on a robust legal framework that guides the adjudication of tax cases. Tax assessment is the process by which the Lower Adjudication Authority (LAA) determine a tax liability identifying the escaped tax as well as tax related to illegitimate claims. A well-established set of judicial principles governing adjudication are extended to the assessment proceedings to ensure a fair and transparent process. The LAA is bound to uphold judicial principles while effectively resolving disputes. However, this has ultimately failed and the current litigation system is facing a growing crisis. The Courts are overburdened with an increasing number of tax disputes, despite the ample alternative mechanism attached to the System. This directly results from the failure of LAA to adhere to judicial principles during the assessment process, ultimately resulting in delayed justice or injustice. According to the National Judicial Data Grid1, the total number of tax cases pending before various High Courts as of March 2024 is 58,195. Thus, through a comprehensive analysis of jurisprudence, procedural frameworks, and empirical data, this research intends to explore the core principles governing adjudication in tax matters and the characterization of tax assessments which is the more critical and contested issue in tax litigation; Delve into the potential of reinvigorating tax adjudication at the officer level to streamline the system, reduce backlog, and uphold core principles like due process and fair hearing; and address the procedural reforms aiming at alleviating the burden on courts and restoring the primacy of adjudicative principles within the litigation landscape.
The COVID-19 pandemic caused big changes in how companies buy and sell each other, known as mergers and acquisitions (M&A). This paper looks at how the pandemic affected M&A all over the world, showing how different industries were impacted, the problems dealmakers faced, and the creative solutions they came up with. By studying real-life examples and analyzing the data, it shows what we've learned from the pandemic and gives advice on how to handle M&A in the future. It talks about the importance of being flexible, using technology better, and teaming up with others to stay strong and keep growing after the pandemic is over.
The surroundings is the maximum important element within the global since it simply impacts how humanity develops and improves in all of its endeavours. Prehistoric Indians believed that safeguarding the natural global—which incorporates water, soil, air, timber, and animals—was a responsibility. However, however, due to modernization, digitization, and new innovations like nuclear power flowers, carbon capture, and thermal electricity flowers, amongst other matters, herbal resources are being used carelessly, leading to troubles like acid rain, global warming, and climate exchange. We must protect the environment without delay due to the fact it's far critical to our health and way of existence. Indian judges have become an increasing number of concerned with preserving and protecting the environment for both modern and future generations. The higher judiciary of India has been doing an incredible job shielding the surroundings which has been for more than two decades. The judiciary, and the Apex Court specifically, fulfilled their constitutional obligations to protect environmental problems. The judiciary did now not assume two times to take on administrative responsibilities and, in a numerous instance, assembled professional committees to endorse ways to stop the nation's tanneries and industries from releasing environmental pollutants into the air. Thus, the aim of this research paper is to investigate the Indian judiciary's seasoned-environmental stance with regards to overseeing the execution of rules.
Community service punishment is a legal consequence where individuals convicted of certain crimes are required to complete unpaid community service as a form of restitution or rehabilitation. Instead of going to jail, offenders are given tasks like cleaning public areas, helping charitable organizations, or participating in community-centered activities. This type of punishment aims to teach responsibility, encourage accountability, and give offenders a chance to give back to society. Community service punishment is used in many countries around the world, including various European countries, the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, and Australia. It is seen as effective in reducing prison overcrowding, supporting rehabilitation, and lowering incarceration rates, while allowing offenders to contribute positively to their communities. The shift towards using community service as a punishment in India, as outlined in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, signifies a move away from solely punitive measures towards a more comprehensive and rehabilitative approach to justice. This change recognizes the need to address the underlying causes of criminal behavior, promote rehabilitation, and encourage individuals to take responsibility for their actions, especially for minor offenses. However, there may be challenges in implementing community service punishment in India due to socioeconomic factors, cultural diversity, and existing legal structures.
Insolvency is the state of not being able to repay a loan; insolvency arises when an individual, business, organization, or association fails to satisfy its debt within the allotted time frame. On the other hand , bankruptcy is a legal action initiated when a person, business, or company cannot repay unpaid debts. Bankruptcy starts with a petition to the court made by the entity that owes money to its creditors. However, the procedure to be followed for the petition of bankruptcy varies in different countries. This research will deal with the insolvency and bankruptcy procedure of the Indian jurisdiction. The study will focus on the Indian statute and regulations with concern to insolvency, which resulted in the development of the Insolvency code, 2016. The principle goal is to find out the development of real estate insolvencies and the status of home buyers. In 2017, the National Company law Tribunal and the Appellant Tribunal had the first fortuity to ponder the footing of allottees within the IBC framework. The paper will discuss all the cases and amendments with respect to real estate.
Global warming is glaring problem of the modern world. Since nature has endowed Earth with a clean and healthy climate, having an uncontaminated environment is a fundamental and basic human right. However, India's rapid population growth, modernization, poverty, new innovations, and other factors have significantly affected the physical and chemical makeup of the environment, leading to the problem of global warming. This is because natural resources have been misused and overused. Environmental issues are now major concerns in many regions of the country, hence finding a balance between economic development and the natural environment is crucial. In India, attempts have been undertaken recently to manage the environment in a sustainable way. Since 1972, numerous national initiatives have been implemented through the enactment of various national laws with the aim of mitigating the effects of global warming. This research explores the legal mechanisms employed by India to combat climate change, with a focus on the key statutes, policies, and regulatory frameworks established to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions and promote sustainability. Furthermore, the paper highlights the significance of judicial activism and public interest litigation in advancing environmental protection objectives, citing landmark cases where courts have intervened to ensure compliance with environmental laws and hold polluters accountable. While significant progress has been made, ongoing efforts are essential to effectively mitigate climate change impacts and safeguard the planet for future generations.
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into various industries has been a game-changer, and the legal profession is no exception. As artificial intelligence (AI) systems are being increasingly integrated into various sectors, the question of liability for errors made by these systems has emerged as a significant legal issue. The paper explores the complexities of assigning liabilities when AI systems malfunction or produce erroneous outputs. It examines existing legal frameworks and proposes potential models for liability, including the roles of developers, users, and manufacturers as well as examines the impact of these technologies on traditional legal roles and the broader implications for the future of law. With AI systems capable of performing tasks such as document review, legal research, and even predictive analysis, with higher efficiency and lesser time, the demand for certain legal jobs are diminishing. This evolution is prompting a re-evaluation of the skills required for legal practice, with an emphasis on technological proficiency and interdisciplinary knowledge. The paper also explores the ethical and regulatory challenges posed by AI in the legal field, advocating for adaptive strategies to ensure that legal professionals can navigate and thrive in this changing landscape. This paper also presents a comparative analysis of the utilization and safety measures of AI in the judiciary on an international field. It identifies the key areas where India lags in adopting AI technologies for judicial processes and ensuring their safe implementation.
Humanity stands at the heart of every nation, influencing the dynamics of rights, duties, social welfare, and economic growth. These factors collectively shape the socio-cultural fabric of modern countries and contribute to the intricate web of diplomatic relations between nations. In the context of India, a profound perspective on international relations is encapsulated in the Sanskrit phrase from Hindu texts, "VASUDHAIVA KUTUMBAKAM," translating to "The World Is One Family." This ethos underscores India's approach to global affairs, fostering a belief in interconnectedness and shared prosperity. India's historical engagement, from the ancient silk routes facilitating trade to contemporary participation in international nuclear treaties focusing on non-proliferation, reflects its evolving position in the global arena. The nation has consistently pursued bilateral efforts in areas ranging from national security to oil and energy dependence, emphasizing the significance of cultural exchange as a catalyst for diplomatic relations. Integral to the foundation of strong international relations are robust diplomatic negotiations, where diplomats play a pivotal role in executing treaties and agreements between nations. The art of diplomacy emerges as an established method for influencing the decisions and behaviors of foreign governments and populations. It emphasizes dialogue, negotiation, and various diplomatic measures as alternatives to conflict, war, or violence. Diplomats, as official representatives of their respective countries, engage in complex negotiations that extend beyond geopolitical considerations. The concept of diplomatic immunity, a crucial aspect of international relations, has evolved over the years. It is rooted in the mutual reciprocal respect and understanding among diverse countries and their societies, creating a framework that enables diplomats to fulfill their roles without undue interference. In essence, this exploration delves into the multifaceted dimensions of India's engagement with the global community, tracing its historical roots, contemporary pursuits, and the critical role of diplomacy in shaping international relations. The intricate dance of diplomacy continues to be a key instrument in fostering understanding, collaboration, and shared progress among nations.
This article investigates the indispensable role of arbitration in navigating the aspect of mergers and acquisitions (M&A) disputes. M&A transactions, crucial for corporate growth, often encounter conflicts related to valuation, representations, and post-closing adjustments. Traditional litigation, with its drawbacks of time and cost, proves less than ideal for resolving these complexities. Arbitration emerges as a significant alternative, offering confidentiality, expertise, and efficiency. This article explores the advantages and challenges of arbitration in the M&A context, highlighting the escalating trend of incorporating arbitration clauses in M&A agreements. Examining jurisdictional considerations, the article sheds light on how the choice of venue influences the effectiveness of arbitration in this specialized domain. Through various case studies, this article contributes insights into the evolving landscape of M&A dispute resolution, highlighting the growing significance of arbitration in facilitating efficient and confidential solutions. This article also further discusses the challenges that might be faced with respect to arbitration in M&A disputes. Further, this article discusses the future developments and trends and that assistance that it provides to facilitate the process of arbitration.
The advent of social media has transformed the landscape of communication and interaction in the digital era. Its widespread adoption has turned social media platforms into significant repositories of potential evidence within the legal realm. This article delves into the impact of social media on the legal domain and the legal profession, encompassing aspects such as the law of evidence. Additionally, it scrutinizes the challenges and opportunities that social media presents to legal practitioners. The exponential surge in social media usage has broadened the horizons of electronic evidence available in legal disputes. Social media content, comprising posts, messages, photos, videos, and comments, can play a pivotal role as evidence in a range of legal cases, spanning from civil disputes to criminal investigations. However, the authentication of social media evidence poses a considerable challenge, given its susceptibility to manipulation, fabrication, or deletion. Furthermore, the utilization of social media evidence gives rise to privacy concerns, prompting courts to balance the imperative for relevant evidence with the safeguarding of individuals' privacy rights. Introducing social media evidence often involves navigating the intricacies of the hearsay rule, a task made complex by the prevalence of out-of-court statements on these platforms. Preserving social media evidence is imperative to prevent spoliation and uphold data integrity. Legal professionals are tasked with educating their clients about the obligation to safeguard social media content when litigation is anticipated or initiated. Social media investigations have become an integral component of the pre-trial process, empowering lawyers to gather information about opposing parties, witnesses, or jurors. However, ethical considerations and adherence to rules of professional conduct are crucial to maintaining the integrity of such investigations.
In this digital age, Right to Privacy is a fundamental right which is being acknowledge by different jurisdiction in this world. This research paper deals with a comparative study of right to privacy in India as compared with United Kingdom, concentrating their respective legal frameworks, their major judicial interpretations and examines their differences form a cyber law perspective. The right to privacy in India is elaborated in the landmark Supreme Court judgement “Justice K.S Puttaswamy (Retd.) vs. Union of India (2017)”, which declared privacy as a constitutional right under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. This landmark judgement has generated the legislative and judicial reforms that focuses on protection of personal data in cyberspace. To elaborating modern digital privacy concern, key statutes like Information Technology Act, 2000 and the Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019 are scrutinize to understand their effects and limitations. To the contrary, the United Kingdom has a deep-rooted privacy law, named as Human Rights Act, 1998 and further reinforce by the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) post-Brexit through the Data Protection Act, 2018. The U. K’s privacy framework is elaborated by rigorous data protection standards and strong enforcement mechanisms, considers its commitment to validate privacy rights. This research paper examines the judicial interpretations and legislative measures of both the countries, that elaborates their strengths and weaknesses. It also defines how cultural, historical and political contexts impacts these legal landscapes. Under this paper the comparative analysis, focuses on to provides understanding of the effectiveness of the privacy protection in this digital age. Giving suggestion and recommendations towards synchronizing cyber laws at global level, also to elaborate the challenges raised by rapid technological advancements.
This research article, "Charting the Frontier of Ecological Sustainability: An In-Depth Analysis of Corporate Environmental Stewardship," provides a thorough exploration of the challenges and opportunities associated with corporate environmental practices. It investigates how companies often engage in greenwashing—where marketing efforts create a misleading impression of environmental responsibility—by comparing public claims with actual practices. This examination underscores the importance of genuine sustainability efforts and the risks associated with deceptive environmental claims. The paper integrates the concept of business model innovation, emphasizing the need for companies to align their operations with authentic sustainable practices to avoid greenwashing pitfalls. It explores how business models can be designed to enhance profitability while genuinely contributing to ecological and social progress. Through an analysis of data manipulation and misrepresentation in ESG reporting, the paper highlights the critical role of accurate and transparent reporting in maintaining investor trust and ensuring accountability. Furthermore, the misuse of ESG funds is addressed, illustrating the need for rigorous oversight to ensure that investments adhere to the advertised environmental, social, and governance criteria. Social negligence, particularly in the context of labor rights and global supply chains, is also examined to highlight the broader implications for stakeholder relationships and ethical governance. The paper identifies systemic challenges such as the lack of standardized ESG reporting frameworks, data quality issues, regulatory uncertainties, and the risk of greenwashing. By connecting these challenges to the broader context of business model innovation and sustainable practices, the paper advocates for a more integrated approach to ESG. This approach ensures that corporate activities genuinely reflect their environmental and social commitments, aiming to create business models that drive real sustainability and foster transparency and accountability in corporate environmental stewardship.
The article provides an in-depth comparison of two major retirement savings options available to Indian employees: the Employee Provident Fund (EPF) and the National Pension Scheme (NPS). The article begins by explaining the foundational aspects of each scheme, including their objectives, eligibility criteria, and the mechanisms through which contributions are made. It outlines the benefits associated with EPF, such as mandatory contributions, government-backed security, and tax advantages, while also discussing the advantages of the NPS, including its flexibility in investment choices, potential for higher returns, and additional tax benefits. The comparison is further extended to cover the tax implications of both schemes, focusing on the tax deductions and exemptions under Sections 80C and 80CCD of the income tax act. The article highlights the differences in withdrawal rules, annuity options, and liquidity, which are crucial for retirement planning. Additionally, the article evaluates, these schemes from the perspective of various worker demographics, including salaried employees in the private and public sectors, self-employed individuals, and those with varying risk tolerances and retirement goals. In conclusion, the article provides a set of guidelines to help readers determine the most suitable option based on their individual circumstances, such as risk appetite, long-term financial goals, and the level of control they wish to have over their retirement corpus. The aim is to empower Indian workers with the knowledge required to make informed decisions about their retirement savings, ensuring financial security in their post-retirement years.
Child labour poses a pervasive issue in Indian society, adversely impacting the mental health development of children by depriving them of their rightful childhood. This article begins by elucidating the meaning and causes of child labour. A primary driver is the widespread unemployment and underemployment among the economically disadvantaged adult population, exacerbated by the rapid growth of the population. The consequences of subjecting a child to such conditions are then outlined, encompassing issues like malnutrition, susceptibility to sexual harassment due to limited awareness, and a lack of understanding about societal norms, laws, and basic knowledge. The article subsequently delves into the economic ramifications of child labour, highlighting that while a select few may experience short-term gains, the long-term negative effects on the nation's economy are profound. Illiterate children who are deprived of education and forced into labour do not contribute to their full potential, hampering overall economic growth. Turning to the legal perspective, international conventions have sought to establish a global legal framework addressing child labour. The Constitution of India, 1950, specifically under Article 21(A), mandates free and compulsory education for all children aged 6–14. Notably, the law prohibits children under the age of 14 from working in any government or private sector, with exceptions made for certain situations, such as when a child is involved in running a family business. The article concludes by exploring societal measures to prevent the escalation of child labour. It suggests various approaches, including analyzing the prevailing situation, reviewing national laws pertaining to child labour, and implementing protective measures such as verifying the age of employees and identifying hazardous forms of work.
The intersection of neuroscience and alternative dispute resolution (ADR) is an approach to resolving conflicts by integrating insights into human brain functioning. This paper explores how neuroscience can enhance ADR techniques, providing a deeper understanding of the psychological aspects of conflict and how these insights can be applied within the Indian legal context to improve outcomes and address the unique challenges of the Indian societal framework. By focusing on neuroscience's potential to shape ADR processes, the aim of this paper is to propose a more empathetic and effective system that addresses the roots of conflict rather than merely the symptoms.
The regulation of arms in India has a multifaceted history, shaped by colonial influences and contemporary security considerations. This research paper seeks to investigate the development, implications, and enforcement of arms legislation in India, particularly focusing on the Arms Act of 1959. While examining the evolution of the law relating to control of firearms in India, author has highlighted the differential objective behind legislation enacted by the British Government and Indian government respectively. This research paper emphasizes upon the primary goal of the government while enacting the Arms Act of 1959 i.e., to regulate the possession and use of firearms and ammunition, with the aim of upholding public order and safety. This paper examines the legal definitions of arms and ammunitions, the judicial understandings of relevant cases, and the societal ramifications of arms proliferation. It emphasizes the significant differences between various types of weapons, such as firearms and toy guns, and examines important legal cases that have influenced the interpretation of the law. The paper highlights the legislature's commitment to combating unauthorized access to arms in light of mounting national security and terrorism concerns. Furthermore, it explores the evidentiary prerequisites for categorizing an object as an “arm” and the legal ramifications of possessing unlicensed weapons. The paper also examines the enforcement challenges and the necessity for stricter regulations to ensure public safety. Through a comprehensive analysis of case law and statutory provisions, the paper aims to offer clarity on the legal framework governing arms in India, fostering a better understanding of the implications for individuals and society at large.
Integration of Financial markets across different countries and the growing financial interdependence among them refers to financial globalization and in today’s era of financial globalization, India’s establishment of its own International Financial Service Centre (IFSC) represents a significant development. As one of the world’s largest and fastest-growing economies, India recognized the necessity of creating a financial center to boost domestic economic growth, enhance liquidity, expand the labor pool, and import international financial services. International Financial Service Center Authority (IFSCA) is a primary regulator of IFSC in India. Consequently, India’s first IFSC was set up in Gujarat International Finance Tech-City (GIFT), opening the doors to numerous international financial institutions and transactions. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI), a key regulator of IFSC in GIFT City, has implemented various changes through notifications and circulars. The most recent change permits resident individuals to facilitate remittances under the Liberalized Remittance Scheme (LRS) in GIFT IFSCs. These remittances enhance liquidity in the IFSC ecosystem and contribute to economic growth. Liberalized remittance scheme was introduced in 2004, way before IFSC was set up in India, accelerating foreign exchange in India especially for Indian resident individuals. Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 stated all permitted and prohibited transactions to facilitate foreign exchange which is also applicable for remittances under LRS. In recent years, GIFT IFSC has made substantial progress in promoting the free flow of finance and ease of doing business. However, it had not fully benefited Indian residents until the recent permission for remittances directly through the LRS in the IFSC. This allows Indian residents to fully engage with GIFT IFSC. This paper delves more into the recent RBI notification under the LRS to GIFT IFSC, providing a brief overview of the IFSC, GIFT City, the LRS regime, and the transformative impact of the RBI’s new notification.
Online Dispute Resolution (ODR) is an emerging field that has the potential to transform dispute resolution in India. This research paper begins with a prologue to ODR and its importance in India. This paper then goes on to examine the present condition of ODR in India in depth, covering the legal structure and framework, developments and changes, and growth of ODR in India. The paper further analyzes the benefits of ODR, the comparison of ODR to traditional dispute resolution techniques in India, and the assessment of the challenges that ODR faces in India. The paper gives potential answers to these challenges to ensure the widespread adoption of ODR in India. This research paper concludes with the capability of ODR to transform dispute resolution in India and its future prospects. This paper aims to give a comprehensive analysis of the challenges, opportunities, and prospects of ODR in India. Finally, suggestions for further research and the limitations of the study are given.
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into international trade is revolutionizing global commerce, presenting both unprecedented opportunities and complex challenges. This article explores the intersection of AI and international trade law, focusing on how AI technologies are reshaping trade processes, regulatory frameworks, and intellectual property rights . By examining case studies, including India's use of AI in customs operations, its approach to intellectual property rights for AI-generated works, and the impact of AI on e-commerce, the article highlights the evolving legal and regulatory landscape. India’s strategic focus on AI and its implications for trade law are discussed, emphasizing the need for updated international regulations that address data sovereignty, IP protection, and cross-border data flows. The article argues for greater international cooperation to develop harmonized regulations that balance innovation with fair trade practices. Recommendations include strengthening international collaboration, modernizing domestic legal frameworks, and promoting ethical AI practices. This study underscores the importance of adapting international trade laws to effectively manage the rapid advancements in AI, ensuring that global trade remains equitable and efficient.
With the goal of protecting witnesses who are vital to the judicial process, the efficacy of India's witness protection program is a crucial concern for the criminal justice system. This abstract looks at the program's effectiveness in protecting witnesses by examining its design, difficulties, and results. The Witness Protection Scheme, 2018 established India's witness protection program aims to safeguard witnesses from threats, coercion, or reprisals in order to foster a stronger legal system. The program offers a number of safeguards, including identity theft, relocation, and secrecy. Nevertheless, a number of obstacles, such as inadequate funding, lengthy bureaucracy, and uneven execution among states, limit its efficacy. Even while the program has been successful in high-profile situations like terrorism and organized crime, the absence of consistent criteria and procedural rigor limits its overall influence. Its dependability is further compromised by the lack of committed financing and qualified staff. Furthermore, the effectiveness of the program frequently depends on the witness's cooperation and the competence of the legal system to provide a prompt trial. Although the Witness Protection Scheme in India is a big start in the right direction, systemic problems and a lack of funding limit how effective it can be. For the program to carry out its goal and make a significant contribution to the criminal justice system, it is imperative that these issues be addressed through more financing, training, and standard operating procedures.
The growing threats posed by environmental and climate crises have recently become a significant force for the nations to engage investors as key players in pursuing sustainable growth. This involves integrating Environmental, Social, and Governance criterions into investment strategies. As sustainability and responsible practices gain prominence, Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) investing is increasingly recognized as a transformative force on global financial markets. In India, ESG investing is gaining importance, fuelled by increasing regulatory demands, investor interest, and a growing recognition of responsible business practices. This research paper aims to thoroughly examine and critically assess the concept of ESG investing along with ESG in action. The study explores the evolution, recent regulations, strategies, challenges, and future prospects of ESG investing in India. Additionally, it seeks to address the pertinent question of whether ESG investments yield higher returns and investigates the correlation between strong ESG performance and stock price appreciation. The researchers have employed a doctrinal research methodology to carry out this study. Previous studies have produced mixed conclusions regarding the correlation between ESG investments and their financial returns. However, the authors of this research, after accounting for the country’s commitment and the companies’ dedication to sustainable growth, along with recent data supported by ongoing regulations such as mandatory CSR & BRSR and rising investor demand, have identified a positive relationship between ESG performance and financial outcomes. This correlation is demonstrated across various metrics including risk, stock returns, profitability, and long-term performance. However, despite these progressions, challenges remain, such as the necessity for stronger regulatory frameworks, uniform ESG measurement standards, and improved corporate transparency.
This paper explores the transformative potential of three significant legal enactments in India—Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), and Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), all instituted in 2023. These reforms, aimed at revamping the archaic legal system inherited from the British era, are pivotal in addressing the pressing issue of women’s safety amidst rising gender-based violence. This study utilises a qualitative legal framework analysis to examine the newly introduced BNS, BNSS, and BSA (2023). Primary sources, such as official legislative texts, and secondary sources, including legal commentaries and scholarly articles, are used for a systematic content analysis. This methodology helps pinpoint vital legislative changes to bolster women’s safety. Our results indicate that the BNS, BNSS, and BSA introduce comprehensive and far-reaching changes to the criminal justice framework, significantly overhauling crime reporting, investigation, and evidence-gathering procedures with an enhanced focus on women’s security. These laws establish more precise definitions of gender-based crimes and offer more stringent penalties for offenders, coupled with protective mechanisms for victims, providing a comprehensive approach to women’s safety. These legislative changes’ reformative steps significantly enhance the procedural, substantive, and evidential aspects of the law, with a focus on expediting processes and integrating digital evidence. However, the success of these measures largely hinges on their implementation, which must navigate the challenges of resource allocation, technological infrastructure development, and shifting societal attitudes towards gender and safety.
This article explores the integration of restorative justice practices into alternative dispute resolution (ADR) mechanisms within the context of criminal cases. Restorative justice, which emphasizes healing, accountability, and community involvement, presents a transformative approach that contrasts with the adversarial nature of traditional criminal justice systems. The adoption of restorative justice in criminal ADR offers a unique opportunity to address the needs of victims, offenders, and communities in a more holistic manner. However, the integration of restorative justice into ADR frameworks is not without challenges. These include legal and procedural constraints, resistance from traditional legal practitioners, concerns about consistency and fairness, and the potential for retraumatization of victims. The article discusses these challenges in detail and proposes strategies to mitigate them, such as enhancing legislative support, providing specialized training for facilitators, and developing clear guidelines and standards. By examining both the opportunities and challenges of integrating restorative justice into alternative dispute resolution for criminal cases, this article contributes to a deeper understanding of how restorative justice practices can be effectively incorporated into criminal justice systems to enhance justice outcomes and support victim recovery.
The rapid advancement of trade and technology has significantly reduced the size of the world, fostering the rise of numerous multinational corporations that establish cross-border business relationships daily. This global business landscape inevitably leads to scenarios where debtors and creditors are situated in different jurisdictions, thereby triggering the application of diverse legal frameworks and the initiation of proceedings in multiple countries. Consequently, it becomes imperative to facilitate efficient asset recovery for creditors abroad and address the complex legal challenges associated with cross-border insolvency. This study meticulously explores the intricate aspects of cross-border insolvency within the Indian context. It traces the historical development of this legal domain, examines the relevant provisions of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) of 2016, and critically evaluates their alignment with the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency. The analysis extends to the practical implications of the Cross-Border Insolvency Rules of 2020 and the key provisions of Draft Z, which was prepared by the Insolvency Law Committee (ILC) based on the Model Law. Additionally, the study investigates the evolution of related legislation through recent judicial decisions. The author concludes by offering fundamental suggestions and recommendations to address the practical challenges within India’s insolvency regime and to bridge the gaps left by existing legislation.
The protection of non-conventional marks is a pressing issue in intellectual property law, which has gained increasing importance in recent years. Non-conventional marks are trademarks that deviate from the typical word, logo, or combination of both. They encompass a diverse range of identifiers, including sounds, scents, colours, shapes, and even moving images like GIFS etc. These marks present a distinctive challenge because they do not conform to traditional trademark categories. One of the key challenges in protecting non-conventional marks is establishing distinctiveness. In many legal systems, a mark must be capable of distinguishing the goods or services it represents from those of others. Demonstrating this distinctiveness for non-conventional marks often requires additional evidence and creativity. To overcome these challenges, intellectual property laws worldwide have evolved to accommodate non-conventional marks. Many countries have recognized the need to provide protection to these innovative forms of branding. In the United States, for example, sound marks (like the NBC chimes) and trade dress (distinctive product packaging) can be registered as trademarks. Similarly, the European Union permits the registration of non-conventional marks, such as colours (e.g., the Tiffany blue) and three-dimensional shapes (e.g., the Coca-Cola bottle). Despite the challenges in demonstrating distinctiveness, legal systems have adapted to acknowledge the importance of non-traditional branding elements.
The Uniform Civil Code (UCC) represents a cornerstone of India’s constitutional vision, aiming to harmonize personal laws across religions to promote equality and secularism. Despite its foundation in Article 44 of the Constitution, the UCC has faced significant resistance due to its perceived threat to cultural and religious identity. This paper explores the constitutional mandate for a UCC, its necessity in addressing systemic inequalities, and the judicial interpretations that have called for its implementation. Through landmark cases such as Shah Bano, Sarla Mudgal, TMA Pai Foundation, and Shayara Bano, the judiciary has highlighted the incompatibility of discriminatory personal laws with constitutional ideals. This paper also examines the challenges to implementing a UCC, including social resistance, political reluctance, and concerns from minority communities. Finally, it proposes actionable pathways to overcome these obstacles and align India’s legal framework with its constitutional promise of equality and justice.
India, as a developing nation with a burgeoning population and rapidly growing economy, faces significant challenges in addressing climate change while maintaining its developmental aspirations. The National Action Plan on Climate Change (NAPCC), launched in 2008, represents India’s commitment to sustainable development and climate resilience. This research assesses the NAPCC’s framework, objectives, and achievements over the past decade. The study critically evaluates its eight core missions—ranging from solar energy promotion to ecosystem protection—and their alignment with international climate commitments under the Paris Agreement. The analysis reveals mixed outcomes, with notable progress in renewable energy expansion but significant gaps in areas such as water management and agricultural adaptation. Challenges include inadequate inter-ministerial coordination, insufficient funding, and limited community engagement. Furthermore, the study emphasizes the role of emerging technologies, public-private partnerships, and community-driven approaches to achieve the plan's goals. By integrating lessons from global best practices and fostering adaptive governance, the NAPCC can be a transformative force in India’s climate strategy. This research provides actionable policy recommendations to strengthen the NAPCC’s effectiveness in mitigating climate change impacts and ensuring sustainable growth in India. This assessment underscores the importance of adaptive, inclusive, and collaborative strategies to achieve the dual goals of environmental conservation and economic development in the face of global climate challenges.
