VidhiAagaz
International Journal ofLegal Science & Innovation
ISSN 2581-9453 · Open access
International Journal ofLegal Science & Innovation
Cover
Open access

Volume VIII, Issue IV / 2026

July to August 2026 · publishing on a rolling basis

Articles
6
Published
2026
Pages
1 to 66
ISSN
2581-9453

Articles · 6

  • Pages1–756 views
    Abstract. Matrimonial litigation in India occupies a peculiar and troubling place within the legal system: it is simultaneously accused of failing genuine victims of cruelty and domestic violence and of being weaponised against the innocent. This paper argues that these two criticisms are not contradictory but are, in fact, symptoms of the same underlying design failure, namely a system that relies on criminal and quasi-criminal machinery to resolve what are, at their core, deeply human and evidentiary disputes, without building the procedural safeguards, enforcement mechanisms or institutional capacity that such a system requires. Drawing on the statutory framework governing cruelty, maintenance and divorce, and on the trajectory of Supreme Court jurisprudence from Sushil Kumar Sharma to Rajesh Sharma to Social Action Forum for Manav Adhikar, the paper demonstrates how blanket judicial guidelines, however well intentioned, often fail when applied uniformly across a fact-sensitive area of law. It further examines the enforcement deficit that renders even a favourable court order practically meaningless. The paper concludes that reform must treat victim protection and misuse prevention as a single design problem rather than as competing political constituencies.
  • AI, Courts and the Future of Procedural Justice in India: Emerging Challenges for Legal Practice and Ethics

    Dr. Kiran Singh
    Assistant Professor at Faculty of Law, Allahabad Degree College, University of Allahabad, Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh, India
    Pages8–2377 views
    Abstract. The integration of artificial intelligence into judicial and legal systems is now reshaping the administration of justice in India. With more than fifty million cases pending across courts, the Indian judiciary has increasingly turned to technological solutions, including the e-Courts Mission Mode Project, the Supreme Court’s SUVAS (translation) and SUPACE (research assistance) tools, and AI-driven transcription and case-management systems. Though these initiatives promise greater efficiency, accessibility and reduced delays, they at the same time raise a fundamental question about the integrity of procedural justice, a foundation of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India. This paper examines how AI adoption intersects with core principles of procedural fairness, namely the right to a fair hearing, transparency, reasoned decision-making, impartiality and accountability. It identifies key challenges, including algorithmic bias arising from skewed or incomplete datasets, the opacity of “black box” systems that undermine the duty to give reasons, the risk of automation bias among judges and lawyers, and concerns over data privacy in light of K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023. The paper also covers the problem of “hallucinated” citations produced by generative AI tools, which has already surfaced in courts internationally and in India, and its implications for the duty of candour owed to the court. The paper further analyses the obligations of advocates under the Bar Council of India Rules, including competence, diligence, confidentiality and duty to the court, in an environment where AI-assisted drafting and research are becoming commonplace. It also explores questions of liability, supervision and professional responsibility when AI outputs are relied upon, and the risk that unequal access to technology may deepen disparities in access to justice. The main contention is that AI should function strictly as an aid to judicial reasoning rather than a substitute, so that technological efficiency advances, rather than erodes, the constitutional promise of fair procedure.
  • Balancing Integrity and Accountability in Corporate Governance to Mitigate Fraud

    Dr. Aswathi SukumaranORCID iD
    Assistant Professor at School of Law, Vels Institute of Science, Technology & Advanced Studies (VISTAS), Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
    Pages24–3464 views
    Abstract. Corporate fraud is a widespread problem that compromises the credibility of financial systems, disrupts companies, and diminishes public confidence in economic institutions. Corporate fraud in India has emerged as a major issue, marked by numerous high-profile incidents of financial misreporting, embezzlement, insider trading, and resource misallocation. Such fraudulent acts frequently stem from deficient corporate governance, insufficient regulatory monitoring, economic pressures, and a culture of impunity within organizations. The ramifications of corporate fraud are extensive, affecting investors, employees, customers, and the broader economy, and frequently resulting in financial losses, reputational harm, and legal issues. This article is a doctrinal study examining the categories and consequences of corporate fraud in India, highlighting the significance of combating fraud. It underscores the necessity for enhanced corporate governance, improved law enforcement, technical measures, and protection for whistleblowers to address fraud effectively. Ultimately, cultivating a culture of openness, accountability, and ethical conduct within Indian enterprises is crucial for reducing the dangers of corporate fraud and maintaining sustainable growth in the nation’s corporate sector.
  • Waiting for the Dues: Time Bound Insolvency and the Claims of Gig Workers under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016

    Kavya S
    LL.M. Student at SRM School of Law, SRM Institute of Science and Technology, Kattankulathur, Tamil Nadu, India
    Pages35–4368 views
    Abstract. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 was built around one promise, that a distressed company would be resolved or liquidated within a fixed period. Section 12 caps the corporate insolvency resolution process at 180 days, with a further 90 days allowed in limited cases, and the Supreme Court has held that the outer limit of 330 days, including time spent in litigation, must ordinarily be respected and may be exceeded only in exceptional cases. This article asks how that compressed timeline affects gig workers, whose money claims against platform companies are often unpaid fees, incentives, or deductions that do not fit neatly into any category of creditor under the Code. Using a doctrinal method and a close reading of leading Supreme Court decisions, the article argues that the time bound process protects gig workers in one sense, because it stops a distressed platform from holding its assets indefinitely, but it can also harm them. Their claims are usually ranked low in the distribution waterfall, they have no organised voice in the committee of creditors, and the moratorium freezes their individual recovery efforts. The article concludes with suggestions for clearer classification of platform dues and for targeted interim relief during the resolution period.
  • Pages44–5655 views
    Abstract. The Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (“the Atrocities Act”) was enacted to punish and deter caste-based indignity, not to reach every dispute in which the parties are of different castes. Over the past twenty years, and more clearly since 2020, the Supreme Court of India has held that an insult, abuse or scuffle does not constitute an offence under sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the Act unless the prosecution can demonstrate a caste-based intent to humiliate or abuse by caste name. This paper traces that doctrine of “intent to humiliate” through Swaran Singh, Hitesh Verma, Shajan Skaria, Karuppudayar and the latest decisions of the Court. It examines the burden of proof on mens rea, including after the 2015 Amendment changed “on the ground that” to “knowing” in section 3(2)(v), added section 3(2)(va) and introduced a presumption of knowledge of caste identity in section 8(c) of the Act. The paper contends that the judicial gloss and the statutory amendments can be reconciled only if the three elements of knowledge, intent to humiliate and caste-based motive are analytically separated, and it suggests an analytical test for courts that is both structured and context-sensitive.
  • Law in the Wake of Outrage: Reshaped Definition of Rape Based on Mathura and Nirbhaya Case

    Jeevitha M
    Assistant Professor at Sathyabama Institute of Science and Technology (Deemed to be University), Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
    Laxmi Priya M
    Assistant Professor at Vels Institute of Science, Technology and Advanced Studies (VISTAS), Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
    Pages57–6658 views
    Abstract. This paper explores how moments of collective outrage have reshaped India’s legal understanding of rape from rigid colonial definitions to survivor-centered reforms. The Mathura custodial rape case (1979) revealed how silence was misread as consent and how a woman’s sexual history was weaponized against her. Public protest following the case led to the 1983 amendment, which introduced evidentiary safeguards like Section 114A of the Indian Evidence Act, shifting the burden of proof in custodial rape cases. Decades later, the Nirbhaya gang rape (2012) shook the nation’s conscience and prompted sweeping changes through the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013. The definition of rape was expanded beyond penile penetration to include oral, anal, and object-based violations. New categories of aggravated rape were introduced, and procedural reforms aimed to protect survivors from secondary trauma during trial. Most recently, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, has codified these reforms, defining rape in Section 63 and reinforcing harsher penalties for heinous acts in the sections that follow, and embedding survivor dignity into the legal process. By tracing this trajectory from the silenced voice in the Mathura case to the national reckoning of the Nirbhaya case, the paper argues that legal reform in India has been driven not just by jurisprudence, but by the moral force of public outrage. Yet, the journey toward justice remains ongoing, demanding not only better laws but deeper empathy.